If I was going to do this, it would be the fork slider I modified.
It's easy to weld shape and paint.
It's almost impossible to weld polished aluminum and have it blend decent.
Plus if you ever want to go back, 2 minutes with a grinder, a little paint and done. Plus your expensive break plate is still unmodified.
Anyone should be able to easily (And cheaply) weld the slider. Not so the break plate.